Home > Ask Our Experts > Would Owning a Dog Cure Child's Nervousness?

Would Owning a Dog Cure Child's Nervousness?

By: Hsin-Yi Cohen BSc, MA, MSt - Updated: 4 Sep 2010 | comments*Discuss
 
Pet Children Dogs Nervous Fear Scared

Q.

I have 3 children ages 10, 7 and 6 years old. The problem is the 10 year old is comfortable with dogs and would love to have one as would I, but the younger two are quite nervous around dogs.

We have borrowed a relative's dog in the past and the younger children take a very long time to get used to it, if at all (it's a working dog who is quite silly). We keep thinking about getting our own dog to either 'kill' or 'cure' the situation.

I'm not sure how to deal with this situation as I don't know how to compromise between all the children. What do you do when most of the family want a dog but other members are quite scared, I feel that the older child will be missing out. Can you give me any advice?

(KH, 17 February 2009)

A.

Having the right kind of dog could help a child overcome his nervousness of dogs but having the wrong kind of dog could make things worse and give the child a severe phobia.

Most children like and enjoy the company of animals – those who don’t have often had a bad experience and therefore associate animals with fear or pain. If this is the case, it may take some time – and many positive encounters – for the child to regain his confidence around animals. Thus in this case, it is important not to just expose the child to any animal – possibly risking another negative encounter and reinforcing his fear – but instead, carefully choosing a gentle, well-behaved animal for the child to interact with, so he can overcome his fear or dislike and come to enjoy the animal’s company. Remember, though, there are some children who are just not that into pets and nothing will change that, so it is important to respect their feelings as well.

In this situation, if the younger children have not vehemently declared a hatred or deep fear of dogs, then it may be worth thinking about getting a pet dog for the family, especially as other members are so keen.

However, the important thing is to choose the right breed – one that is not too strong, boisterous or dominant in personality, which may be difficult for inexperienced owners to control – and also one of a manageable size. In general, smaller dogs are easier to handle and control although toy breeds can also be more nervous and snappy, whereas many large, family dogs are much more tolerant of children and are easier to handle, despite their size.

Involving the younger children in the choice of dog may help enormously. They may not fear all dogs but simply large, boisterous types or shaggy types or small, yappy types – or dogs like the neighbour’s! They may find certain breeds or types very “cute” and this may help them be more accepting of the dog. In addition, involving them in the selection process helps them feel more in control and therefore less frightened of the concept.

Training is the key – bringing in a wild, out-of-control, nipping puppy will do nothing to allay the younger children’s fears; conversely, enjoying the company of a well-behaved dog may encourage the younger children to view dogs in a different light. People often dislike or fear dogs due to bad behaviour they have seen or received – they are often surprised when they meet a well-behaved, well-trained dog and discover that they don’t hate dogs as much as they thought!

Raising a puppy and training it well requires a lot of work, patience, time and effort and this may not be easy for a mother with 3 young children – therefore, it may be worth considering an older, gentle dog from a rescue shelter: one which has been trained and socialised and assessed, so that you know exactly what kind of dog you are getting. Staff at rescue shelters are very knowledgeable and experienced and would be able to match your family to the right dog for your situation. And many dogs are in shelters through no fault of their own – perhaps due to a marriage break-up or owner death or illness – and they would make wonderful family pets.

Once you have the right kind of dog – a gentle, mild type who does not jump up or behave in other excitable ways which may frighten young children – then getting the younger children involved in the daily care and training of the dog may also help them overcome their fears and start to take pride in their “new pet”.

If, however, the younger children show an extreme fear of dogs, then it would be perhaps unfair to add a dog to the family – not just for their sake but also for the dog's. Too many dogs are adopted into the wrong family situation and then abandoned again when they don’t suit. In this case, it may be better for the oldest child to get her “dog fix” another way – perhaps by helping to walk and take care of a neighbour’s dog or volunteering at a dog shelter. As the children grow older, they may gradually change their attitudes and you could revisit the situation again in a few years.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Claire
    Re: Introducing a Kitten to Other Cats
    Hi I've just rescued a five month old male kitten from a family who could no longer look after him turtle to health…
    21 February 2019
  • Mady
    Re: Introducing a Kitten to Other Cats
    Our family has an older cat, maybe 14 years, and she can't get along with the kitten, almost 6 months. We crate the kitten…
    12 February 2019
  • Tom
    Re: Dog Laws in the UK
    Hi there, I had someones dogs for two years straight now while owner went away on hollidays, it was only meant be to be few weeks and looked…
    6 February 2019
  • zoey
    Re: Introducing a Kitten to Other Cats
    I got a female kitten 8 weeks ago and my older cat of 12 years keeps hitting and swatting at the kitten. Ive tried…
    31 January 2019
  • Chris
    Re: Keeping Mammals in an Aviary
    Good day. I’m in the prowess of building a biggish outdoor enclosure (for lack of a better word “cage”) It will have a running…
    17 January 2019
  • Lofty
    Re: Pet Injuries That Can be Treated at Home
    My dog has ripped his dew claw off its not bleeding but it's a bit swollen what can I use to help with infection
    14 January 2019
  • Kickinkell
    Re: Introducing a Kitten to Other Cats
    My cat had kittens four month ago and I kept a male kitten now the cat has had another litre will the four month old…
    26 December 2018
  • Star Indigo
    Re: Dog Laws in the UK
    Where are replies to the above comments?Am I missing the advice/ reply section.I can't see any/one. There are important questions being asked…
    17 December 2018
  • Starchild
    Re: Dog Laws in the UK
    Why are there no replies/advice to any of the above questions? Or is there somewhere else you can go to on this site that I'm missing for…
    17 December 2018
  • Concerned citizen
    Re: Dog Laws in the UK
    A man regularly visits one of my neighbours for hours at a time and leaves his dog tied up outside in all weather including icy nights like we…
    15 December 2018